Finding truly memorable sushi in Selden, NY can feel like searching for pearls in a sea of options. From unassuming strip malls to sleek, modern dining rooms, the town offers an array of sushi spots that range from time-tested classics to hidden gems. I still remember my first impromptu dinner at a local sushi bar here. Each plate was a little journey—think delicate slices of salmon, perfectly seasoned rice, and the smiles of families gathered around hibachi flames. It made me realize Selden has a sushi culture all its own; you just need to know where to look.
This guide draws on genuine visits and local insights to spotlight the best halal-friendly sushi experiences in Selden. Whether you’re hunting for a quiet place to savor sashimi or a bustling spot for all-you-can-eat nights, you’ll find an option to suit your mood and cravings. The list ahead unpacks the flavors, textures, and unique charms of each restaurant. Get ready to discover the sushi rolls that locals crave—and perhaps a new favorite of your own.
Where to find the best sushi in Selden, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best sushi in Selden, NY:
- Nishiki Hibachi & Sushi
- Machi Sushi
- Peking Chinese Japanese Food
- Nishiki Sushi Hibachi Restaurant
- Hako Sushi
- Mini Sushi Inc
- New Sushi Palace
- Umami Sushi & Bar
- Sam’s Sushi Bistro
- Golden Buffet
1. Nishiki Hibachi & Sushi
Nishiki Hibachi & Sushi brings an inviting mix of comfort and style to Selden’s sushi scene. Tucked in Independence Plaza, the restaurant’s friendly team and upbeat energy always draw me back. The atmosphere strikes a balance between lively and relaxed, whether you’re enjoying a meal solo or with a group.
What sets Nishiki apart is its dedication to fresh ingredients and clean, consistent flavors. Every plate leaves an impression, from the silky tuna slices to bright, crisp cucumber rolls. Their salmon avocado roll never disappoints—lush fish, creamy avocado, and seasoned rice in every bite.
For a fun experience, try their hibachi alongside classic nigiri or a chef’s special roll. It’s an easy favorite for locals searching for reliable, halal-friendly sushi in Selden.
2. Machi Sushi
Machi Sushi claims its spot on Middle Country Road with an understated charm that never feels rushed or crowded. The first time I dropped in, the friendly staff made me feel like a regular, and the efficient service left a strong impression.
The menu stands out for crisp, colorful rolls and thoughtful vegetarian options. If you love fresh flavors, try the Machi Roll—its clean combination of tuna, cucumber, and avocado is a standout. Their vegetarian avocado cucumber roll is both vibrant and satisfying, delivering exactly what you want from a classic favorite.
Light, delicate cuts of fish and well-balanced portions make every visit a pleasure. Whether you sit down for dinner or grab takeout, Machi Sushi keeps things simple and lets the freshness of their sushi do the talking.
3. Peking Chinese Japanese Food
Peking Chinese Japanese Food sits quietly on Middle Country Road, but don’t be fooled by its modest setting. The first time I stopped in, it was the sheer range of options that caught my eye—Japanese classics paired with familiar Chinese favorites, all in one relaxed space.
The sushi menu shines with its freshness and simplicity. The spicy tuna roll hits a satisfying balance of gentle heat and soft texture, while the vegetable rolls offer a crisp bite that keeps you coming back. Their salmon rolls are a highlight, packed with flavor and always consistent.
Affordable prices and quick service make this a go-to for a casual lunch or a low-key dinner. If you want solid sushi that’s easy on the wallet and served in a friendly atmosphere, Peking Chinese Japanese Food is worth a visit.
4. Nishiki Sushi Hibachi Restaurant
Nishiki Sushi Hibachi Restaurant, nestled in Independence Plaza, is the kind of spot where the staff remembers your favorite roll. My first visit was after a long day—peaceful lighting, easy parking, and the sound of laughter from hibachi tables set the tone.
Nishiki impresses with quality ingredients and a menu that balances adventure and comfort. The sushi bar is steady with skilled hands, turning out clean, flavorful maki and nigiri. Try the yellowtail scallion roll for its bright, fresh taste, or opt for the crunchy cucumber avocado if you prefer something light.
The hibachi is lively and fun, but the sushi here is what keeps me coming back—especially when paired with a warm bowl of miso soup.
5. Hako Sushi
(631) 320-2151Call
Hako Sushi sits comfortably in Selden Plaza with a vibe that’s always laid-back and welcoming. My first meal here was on a quiet evening, and the cozy space made it easy to relax and enjoy each plate.
The kitchen focuses on simple, honest sushi done right. Rolls are made to order, with rice that’s never too heavy and fish that’s always fresh. The spicy salmon roll is a clear standout—zesty, succulent, and balanced in flavor.
The avocado rolls here also deserve a mention for their creamy texture and vibrant color. Hako Sushi is a reliable pick when you want sushi that feels both personal and satisfying. For an unassuming meal done well, this spot is hard to pass up.
6. Mini Sushi Inc
(631) 698-1888Call
Mini Sushi Inc brings a playful energy to Independence Plaza. My first meal here made me a believer in the idea that good things really do come in small packages. The space is humble, but the flavor is anything but ordinary.
What makes Mini Sushi Inc stand out is their consistent commitment to freshness and value. Each roll is neatly prepared, and you’ll notice the attention given to detail, from the way the rice is packed to the presentation of each plate. The classic tuna roll is a must-try—clean, bright, and satisfying.
If you’re looking for something different, their veggie rolls load up on crunchy, fresh ingredients. Mini Sushi Inc delivers sushi that’s approachable, affordable, and perfect for any day of the week.
7. New Sushi Palace
New Sushi Palace on Middle Country Road feels like a celebration every time you walk in. I still remember the lively buzz and eager anticipation from local families gathered around big platters on my first visit. It’s the kind of place where the variety impresses before you even taste a bite.
The all-you-can-eat approach is handled with care and genuine hospitality. Sushi is made to order, so every roll arrives fresh—nothing sits around here. The eel avocado rolls and salmon avocado rolls have clean flavors and tender textures that sum up what makes this spot special.
If you’re visiting with a group, order a mix of classic rolls and specialty veggie options, then sit back as the plates keep coming. New Sushi Palace stands out for high value and a fun, communal atmosphere.
8. Umami Sushi & Bar
Umami Sushi & Bar makes a splash on Middle Country Road with a chill modern vibe and friendly service that never misses a beat. My first evening here, I noticed the team’s genuine enthusiasm for their sushi—each recommendation came with a story or a smile.
What sets Umami apart is their bold flavors and colorful presentation. The spicy tuna roll is a standout, with just enough heat and fresh seaweed that doesn’t overpower. Their veggie dragon roll layers creamy avocado with crisp cucumber for a satisfying, halal-friendly bite.
If you’re dining in, try one of the chef’s special rolls for a creative twist on the classics. Umami Sushi & Bar stays busy for a reason: it’s a place where quality and warmth go hand in hand.
9. Sam’s Sushi Bistro
Sam’s Sushi Bistro in Farmingville feels cozy from the minute you walk in. I first tried it on a rainy afternoon, and the warmth inside matched the welcome at the door. This spot has a loyal local following, and it’s easy to see why.
The sushi is fresh, and the menu features classic rolls with thoughtful touches. Try the salmon cucumber roll—each slice is packed with flavor and always well balanced. The veggie tempura roll is another strong pick, crisp and satisfying without being greasy.
Presentation here is understated but careful, letting the bright colors shine.It’s a reliable choice when you’re craving tasty, straightforward sushi near Selden, with a neighborhood feel that keeps guests coming back.
10. Golden Buffet
Golden Buffet at Centereach Mall has a lively energy and lots of room to spread out. I visited on a Sunday and found families enjoying generous platters and plenty of choices. The buffet format means you can try a bit of everything, at your own pace.
While the selection is broad, the sushi station is a pleasant surprise. Rolls are refilled regularly, so you’ll catch them at their freshest. The cucumber and avocado rolls are consistently good—simple, cool, and great as a palate cleanser during your meal.
Golden Buffet is a solid option when you’re hungry for variety and value. It’s where you can fill up on a spectrum of flavors without stretching your budget.
More Things to Try in Selden, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best sushi restaurants in Selden, NY?
Some favorites include Nishiki Hibachi & Sushi, Machi Sushi, Mini Sushi Inc, and Hako Sushi. Each offers its own twist—whether you want classic rolls, lively hibachi, or a relaxed, family-friendly meal.
Do any sushi places in Selden offer vegetarian or halal-friendly options?
Yes, plenty of spots offer fresh vegetable rolls and dishes suitable for halal diets. Machi Sushi and Umami Sushi & Bar are known for their vegetarian rolls, while most restaurants note their ingredients for peace of mind.
Is takeout or delivery available from sushi restaurants in Selden?
Almost all sushi spots, including Nishiki Hibachi & Sushi and Machi Sushi, offer takeout. Many also deliver through their own service or third-party apps, perfect for nights in.
Where can I find affordable sushi in Selden?
Golden Buffet, Mini Sushi Inc, and Peking Chinese Japanese Food stand out for value. You’ll get a solid meal without spending a fortune, whether you want a la carte or buffet-style options.
What should I try as a first-timer to sushi in Selden?
Start with salmon or tuna rolls if you’re new to sushi. If you prefer, avocado and cucumber rolls give a light, flavorful introduction. Many places craft these staples with care, so you can’t go wrong.
