Finding good sushi in North Babylon, NY is easier than you might think, especially if you’ve ever craved those perfect slices of salmon or a roll that tastes as fresh as a summer breeze. My first real sushi quest here surprised me in all the right ways: a quiet restaurant off Deer Park Avenue, simple miso soup, then a plate of tuna nigiri so delicate, it just melted away. North Babylon isn’t the place you’d expect to find this kind of care put into seafood, but it’s packed with unassuming spots where sushi is taken seriously.
If you want sushi without the fuss, or somewhere you can actually relax and savor every bite, you’re in luck. Local restaurants offer crisp ingredients, cozy atmospheres, and genuine craft. Whether you’re a strict purist or love creative rolls, there’s a spot that matches your mood. Consider this your guide to the hidden gems and celebrated favorites, so you can skip the guessing and get right to the good stuff.
Where to find the best sushi in North Babylon, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best sushi in North Babylon, NY:
- Sushi Express
- Hibachi Grill and Supreme Buffet
- China Buffet City
- Eastern Babylon Chinese & Japanese Restaurant
- Teriyaki Express
- Mizuki Sushi
- Fancy Lee Asian Bistro ’n’ sushi
- Kabuki Sushi Inc
- Kumo Sushi
- Takumi Hibachi and Sushi Lounge
1. Sushi Express
Sushi Express feels like a hidden gem on Deer Park Avenue. The first time I stopped in, a friend insisted I try their eel avocado roll and shrimp tempura roll. The fish tasted chilled and clean, and the rice had that slight warmth you chase at the better spots.
Sushi Express stands out for how fast they turn out your meal without ever sacrificing freshness. Everything from the nigiri to the maki has a careful touch, but without any fuss or long waits. Even if you’re just grabbing takeout, staff greet you like a regular—it’s low-key, but genuine.
The salmon and tuna rolls here shine a bit brighter than most, and their classic avocado rolls are perfect if you want that unbeatable mix of creamy and crisp. This is reliable, unfussy sushi done right.
2. Hibachi Grill and Supreme Buffet
Hibachi Grill and Supreme Buffet delivers exactly what its name promises: a sprawling buffet with endless options. My first visit was on a Saturday, and the place had a steady hum—families, groups, solo diners all filling plates. Here, the sushi bar keeps things simple and approachable, with fresh rolls topped off fast as soon as the platter empties.
If you like to experiment, this is the spot. The buffet lets you try a mix of sushi, from classic cucumber and avocado rolls to brighter bites with salmon and tuna. Nothing sits around for long, so the sushi stays firm and flavorful.
Try the California roll and the seaweed salad—both pack in more flavor than you’d expect at a buffet. For a casual lunch with plenty of options, this spot delivers.
3. China Buffet City
(631) 274-0888Call
China Buffet City packs a lot of variety into their busy dining room. I wandered in with friends on a rainy evening and was surprised by how inviting the buffet setup felt. There’s always a stack of sushi rolls ready, and staff replenish often, which means you won’t get limp or dried-out pieces.
This spot stands out for its sheer range—you can build your meal from classics like salmon rolls or keep grabbing fresh cucumber rolls. The sushi tastes better than it needs to at a buffet, and for those who want to sample without over-committing, it’s ideal.
The shrimp tempura roll and spicy tuna roll tend to disappear quickly, so try them first. China Buffet City is perfect if you crave variety and value in one stop.
4. Eastern Babylon Chinese & Japanese Restaurant
(631) 667-8100Call
Eastern Babylon Chinese & Japanese Restaurant is the kind of local spot that feels like it’s been part of the neighborhood forever. One rainy afternoon, I stopped in for a quick lunch and ended up staying longer than expected, thanks to the welcoming staff and peaceful atmosphere.
This restaurant blends Chinese comfort food with a line-up of fresh sushi. The sushi menu offers plenty of choice, and every roll looks like it’s made with an extra bit of care. Their rolls are never skimpy—each piece is packed neatly for both taste and presentation.
The spicy salmon roll and the classic tuna roll make a safe bet here, while the avocado cucumber roll works if you want something light and simple. Eastern Babylon stands out for honest prices and fresh flavors.
5. Teriyaki Express
Teriyaki Express is a no-nonsense spot where you get exactly what you expect—and, often, a little more. I once popped in for a quick meal after work and was surprised by how neatly everything was packed and how friendly the counter service felt. It’s fast casual, but the food feels cared for.
What sets Teriyaki Express apart is how they balance speed with well-made sushi. Fresh ingredients and tight, clean rolls are a constant here, whether you’re dining in or taking out. The rice always seems just right—not too sticky, not too dry.
Order the yellowtail scallion roll and their veggie roll for true highlights. The fish is cool and the veggies taste crisp. Teriyaki Express nails quick, fresh sushi—with no hassle.
6. Mizuki Sushi
Mizuki Sushi sits on Commack Road and thrives on simplicity, both in setting and menu. One quiet evening, I stopped by and was greeted by soft jazz and the steady hands of the sushi chef working up front. The pace is calm, even when the orders start to pile in.
Mizuki Sushi stands out for offering solid sushi at prices anyone can appreciate. Every roll is firm and well-balanced—the kind of place where you end up ordering more just because the plates disappear so easily.
The spicy tuna roll and the eel avocado roll are crowd favorites, always tasting fresh and never soggy. For comfortable, no-frills sushi, Mizuki keeps it satisfying and affordable.
7. Fancy Lee Asian Bistro ’n’ sushi
Fancy Lee Asian Bistro ’n’ sushi brings a bit of flair to Babylon’s sushi scene. I stopped in after work one day, greeted by warm lighting and a staff that seemed genuinely happy to explain the menu. The vibe is relaxed, but there’s a clear focus on presentation.
Fancy Lee stands out for playful, elegant sushi that feels special without unnecessary fuss. Every roll arrives looking bright and tempting, often accented with a flourish or a drizzle of subtle sauce.
The mango avocado roll offers a fresh, sweet twist, and the spicy tuna roll brings solid heat without overpowering the fish. If you want sushi that looks as good as it tastes, this is your spot.
8. Kabuki Sushi Inc
Kabuki Sushi Inc sits on South Wellwood Avenue, tucked between small shops. I wandered in late one evening and watched as the chef worked quietly behind the counter, attention fixed on every detail. The calm, understated setting made it easy to relax and settle in.
Kabuki Sushi stands out for its clean flavors and top-notch freshness. The fish is always glossy and cool, while the rice falls apart just right. It’s straightforward sushi, but each dish shows a clear respect for classic technique.
Try the salmon avocado roll and the yellowtail scallion roll—both are crisp, rich, and well wrapped. Kabuki Sushi is the place for anyone who wants traditional, thoughtfully made sushi every time.
9. Kumo Sushi
Kumo Sushi, set in the heart of Bay Shore, has a way of keeping loyal regulars. I remember stepping in on a chilly night, the dining room buzzing with quiet conversations and plates passing briskly. There’s nothing flashy about the space, but the sushi gets straight to the point.
Kumo stands out for perfectly portioned rolls and generous slices of fish. You won’t find filler here—just clean, solid sushi treatments that let the ingredients speak for themselves.
The spicy tuna roll packs a satisfying punch, while the sweet potato roll comes warm and comfortingly crisp. Kumo Sushi is a reliable pick for fresh sushi and relaxed evenings out.
10. Takumi Hibachi and Sushi Lounge
Takumi Hibachi and Sushi Lounge blends energy and elegance on Sunrise Highway. My first visit was with a group of friends, all drawn in by the open hibachi grills and the soft glow from the sushi bar. Even when it’s busy, the atmosphere feels more celebratory than chaotic.
What sets Takumi apart is its variety and quality—especially on the sushi menu. Everything comes out beautifully presented, with an attention to detail that fans of classic sushi will appreciate.
The salmon nigiri and spicy yellowtail roll are especially tender, bursting with clean flavor. For those who love something a bit different, their vegetable rolls show inventive touches. Takumi is where you go for lively dinners and expertly crafted sushi.
More Things to Try in North Babylon, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the must-try sushi spots in North Babylon, NY?
Sushi Express, Eastern Babylon Chinese & Japanese Restaurant, and Hibachi Grill and Supreme Buffet are standout choices for fresh, reliable sushi in North Babylon.
Is there any sushi in North Babylon that’s good for takeout?
Absolutely. Sushi Express and Teriyaki Express are both popular for fast, well-packaged sushi that travels well and stays fresh.
Are there vegetarian sushi options available in North Babylon?
Yes. Most local sushi spots offer classic vegetarian rolls like cucumber, avocado, and sweet potato. Ask for custom combinations if you want to try something new.
Where can I find affordable sushi in North Babylon?
Mizuki Sushi and Fancy Lee Asian Bistro ’n’ sushi both serve well-made sushi at prices that are easy on your wallet, with generous portions to match.
What types of sushi are most popular in North Babylon?
Tuna rolls, salmon rolls, spicy tuna, and shrimp tempura rolls are local favorites. Most places offer a solid selection of maki, nigiri, and specialty rolls.