Finding outstanding sushi in New Hyde Park, NY feels a bit like hunting for rare treasure. This tucked-away part of Long Island surprises first-timers with seriously good rolls and sashimi, far beyond the usual busy strip mall spots. I still remember my first night ordering toro and avocado rolls at a local place, thinking I’d grab a quick bite, only to discover a chef who spoke about rice like it was poetry. It opened my eyes: great sushi teams tradition with a dash of neighborhood charm.
If you’ve hopped from spot to spot, hoping for that slice of perfect tuna, you know the difference is in the detail. When it comes to the best sushi restaurants in New Hyde Park, I know the menu back to front—including where the rice shines, the fish is always fresh, and the rolls show creativity without veering off course. Whether you’re seeking classic nigiri or inventive maki, you’re about to discover all the local gems worth your time.
Where to find the best sushi in New Hyde Park, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best sushi in New Hyde Park, NY:
- Nova Asian Bistro
- Sushiya
- Mikawa Japanese & Korean modern
- Chef Wang
- Sushi Republic
- Bento Sushi
- Sushi Ya
- Ara Sushi & Grill
- Otaki Sushi Inc
- Mizumi
1. Nova Asian Bistro
Nova Asian Bistro slides into the sushi scene with ease, offering a mix of inventive rolls and classic favorites. The bustling yet calm room sets the stage for a meal that never feels rushed. One evening, I watched the chefs slice sashimi with silent focus, and the freshness of each bite made it easy to forget every other sushi night before.
This spot stands out for its attention to detail, from the temperature of the rice to the delicate cut of each piece. The Spicy Salmon Roll gets everything right—plump, clean fish with just the right kick. The Avocado Cucumber Roll offers a simple, bright option that’s always satisfying.
For a treat, order the Nova Special Roll. Its clever layering and balanced flavors sum up what Nova does best: quality over flash, with flavor you won’t forget.
2. Sushiya
Sushiya feels like a local secret that regulars guard with pride. Walking in, there’s always a gentle hum as friends catch up over pretty plates of sushi. I once stopped in on a blustery afternoon and ended up staying longer just for another round of their fresh nigiri.
What sets Sushiya apart is its balance between warmth and quality. The staff never fail to greet you like an old friend, and the fish arrives at your table looking as good as it tastes.
The Yellowtail Jalapeño Roll delivers just-right heat. For something classic, order the Tuna Avocado Roll, which always hits that clean, creamy note. Sushiya’s menu proves simple can be impressive if every detail is right.
3. Mikawa Japanese & Korean modern
Mikawa Japanese & Korean Modern is where two culinary worlds meet without a hint of fuss. The energy here buzzes with the comfort of regulars and the curiosity of newcomers. My first visit started with miso soup and ended with a sushi platter that showed real respect for tradition.
What makes Mikawa stand out is its ability to honor both Japanese and Korean flavors, while never losing focus on quality. Sushi fans will notice the rice—slightly warm, never sticky—pairs beautifully with every cut of fish.
The Salmon Avocado Roll is lush, with buttery salmon that truly shines. The Vegetable Futomaki offers a satisfying bite and a glimpse into the kitchen’s care for even the simplest ingredients. Mikawa’s sushi is precise, honest, and always memorable.
4. Chef Wang
Chef Wang is as clever as its name suggests, blending an approachable atmosphere with a menu that surprises in all the right ways. The polished space is always bustling, but the team never loses their focus on getting each order just right. My first time in, I was struck by the way their sushi platter looked almost like art.
What makes Chef Wang unique is its inventive take on Asian classics and a thoughtful selection for every diner. The Crispy Rice Spicy Tuna roll feels both indulgent and fresh, while the Veggie Roll appeals even when you’re not thinking about vegetables.
The sushi here doesn’t hide behind heavy sauces—it lets fresh fish and neat, careful assembly do the talking. Chef Wang is a place that keeps things interesting, one perfect bite at a time.
5. Sushi Republic
Sushi Republic always feels like you’ve stepped into a spot where sushi is the hero. The clean, airy space is a quiet invitation to slow down and savor. On my last visit, I found myself mesmerized by the detail in each plate—every roll assembled with care, nothing overdone.
Sushi Republic impresses by staying true to the basics but never letting things get dull. Their menu balances classic flavors and creativity, so there’s always something fresh to try.
The Rainbow Roll is a must—vibrant and loaded with a range of fresh fish. For those who crave simplicity, the Cucumber Avocado Roll delivers crisp, balanced flavor that always hits the spot. Sushi Republic’s style: simplicity, done right.
6. Bento Sushi
See Menu
Bento Sushi is the go-to for sushi with speed, without losing out on freshness or flavor. This spot is as convenient as it gets, perfect for those days when you want to grab quality sushi and keep moving. I once stopped in for a quick lunch, grabbed a neatly packed box, and was struck by how fresh everything tasted, even on the go.
Bento Sushi excels at making sushi accessible while still delivering a satisfying experience. Whether you’re a lunch breaker or in search of an easy dinner option, they have something for every pace and palate.
The Salmon Nigiri is always on point—silky, not too firm, and with a clean flavor. The California Roll stays classic and reliable, making Bento Sushi a dependable choice for sushi fans anywhere in New Hyde Park.
7. Sushi Ya
Sushi Ya is the kind of spot where you leave satisfied, whether you’re in for a full sushi spread or just a quick bite. The space always has a comfortable mix of regulars and newcomers, making it easy to relax from the start. My last visit involved a casual dinner that turned into a mini feast once I saw how tempting the menu was.
What gives Sushi Ya its edge is consistency at a friendly price point. Dishes arrive fast, but nothing is rushed—each roll feels fresh and put together with real care.
The Garden Roll is bright and balanced, loaded with crisp vegetables for a refreshing kick. Sushi Ya’s Tuna Hand Roll is another star—clean flavors, no frills, just quality sushi that speaks for itself.
8. Ara Sushi & Grill
Ara Sushi & Grill delivers a blend of Korean and Japanese flavors with the comfort of a neighborhood hangout. On my first visit, I was struck by the open layout and the steady flow of regulars, who seemed to know exactly what they wanted from the menu.
Ara Sushi & Grill stands out for creative presentation and a menu that manages to feel both adventurous and approachable. Each dish arrives with attention to freshness and texture, a signature of the place.
The Sweet Potato Roll is a warm, crowd-pleasing option, while the Avocado Roll keeps things classic and clean. Ara’s rolls reflect a balanced approach—there’s pride in every plate, whether you lean minimalist or love a little flair.
9. Otaki Sushi Inc
Otaki Sushi Inc has that inviting feel where sushi nights feel both special and easy. My most memorable visit was a quiet weeknight—just me, the chef, and the sound of fresh fish being prepared right in front of me.
Otaki Sushi Inc stands out because it brings elevated quality without the fuss. The menu is thoughtfully curated, offering both reliable classics and a few pleasant surprises for regulars seeking something new.
Order the Eel Avocado Roll for a silky, balanced bite that highlights the kitchen’s technique. The Cucumber Roll is crisp, refreshing, and lets the quality of the ingredients come through. Otaki is the place for those looking for sushi crafted with quiet confidence.
10. Mizumi
Mizumi is the spot for anyone who believes variety is the spice of life. The restaurant is spacious and lively, perfect for families or groups who want to sample everything without limits. The first time I visited, I roamed the sushi bar more times than I’d care to admit, thanks to the steady parade of fresh options.
Mizumi shines with its all-you-can-eat approach and the obvious pride in how dishes are prepared and displayed. The buffet layout doesn’t mean skimping on quality—just plenty of choices at your fingertips.
Start with the Assorted Sashimi for clean flavors, and don’t miss the Vegetable Rolls. Mizumi makes sampling a range of well-made sushi remarkably easy, ensuring there’s always something new to try.
More Things to Try in New Hyde Park, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the most popular sushi spots in New Hyde Park?
Some local favorites include Nova Asian Bistro, Sushiya, Otaki Sushi Inc, and Sushi Republic. Each offers its own twist on classic and modern sushi rolls.
Do any New Hyde Park sushi restaurants have vegetarian options?
Absolutely. Most sushi bars in the area, like Chef Wang and Mikawa, serve a range of vegetarian rolls, including avocado, cucumber, and vegetable futomaki.
Are there sushi places in New Hyde Park with takeout or delivery?
Yes, nearly all sushi spots in town, such as Bento Sushi and Sushi Ya, offer both takeout and delivery for quick and easy meals.
Can I find gluten-free sushi in New Hyde Park?
Several restaurants, including Chef Wang, provide gluten-free options—just let your server know what you need.
What sets New Hyde Park’s sushi apart?
Fresh ingredients, careful technique, and a friendly, neighborhood atmosphere make local sushi stand out. Many chefs add personal touches to classic favorites, so there’s always something new to discover.