Craving great sushi in New City, NY isn’t a passing feeling—it’s an itch that mediocre rolls just can’t scratch. I found this out while sitting in a sleek booth, trying my very first piece of toro at a tucked-away spot on Main Street. That single bite—a silky slice, cool and rich—made the difference clear: the right sushi isn’t just dinner, it’s an experience. Since then, I’ve chased down every nigiri, maki, and hand roll worth knowing in town.
Finding top-quality, fresh, and halal-friendly sushi here can be tricky if you don’t know where to look. Many places claim to offer the best, but only a handful deliver that elusive balance of flavor, texture, and trust. Whether you’re new to sushi or a longtime aficionado, the guide ahead will help you skip the guessing game. Ready to discover gems where each bite leaves you planning your next visit? Let’s dive into the spots that make New City a real treat for sushi lovers.
Where to find the best sushi in New City, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best sushi in New City, NY:
- Mizu Asian Bistro & Japanese Steak House
- Kumo Sushi
- New City Sushi
- KOBE Sushi & Lounge
- Miso Nara
- Kobe Fusion Inc
- Cho Cho San
- Momoyama Sushi House
- No1 Sushi
- Unicorn
1. Mizu Asian Bistro & Japanese Steak House
If you’re searching for exquisite sushi in New City, Mizu Asian Bistro & Japanese Steak House deserves a spot on your shortlist. The light-filled dining room mixes modern style with a relaxed vibe that always puts me at ease. Their sushi chefs know how to impress, rolling each order with serious skill and obvious pride.
What truly sets Mizu apart is their attention to freshness and detail. The rice is just right—never clumpy or dry—and the fish has a clean, bright flavor. I still remember biting into their avocado roll, a favorite for vegetarians, and being surprised at how satisfying each piece was.
If you go, try the spicy salmon roll or the yellowtail jalapeño roll. Both showcase what Mizu does best: bold, balanced flavors and beautiful presentation. It’s a solid pick any day of the week for sushi lovers in Rockland.
2. Kumo Sushi
Kumo Sushi draws me back again and again with its cozy atmosphere and creative menu. Tucked near the heart of New City, it’s a spot where you can just settle in and enjoy genuinely good sushi without any fuss. The staff is welcoming, always happy to help you discover something new off the menu.
What sets Kumo apart is the sheer variety. From vegan rolls to specialty platters, there’s something for every palate. The sushi comes out looking almost too good to eat, with vibrant colors and careful plating drawing you in.
I usually go for the sweet potato roll—crispy and satisfying—or the New City roll, which blends avocado and fresh vegetables for a perfect bite. If you’re looking for clean flavors and thoughtful options, this is your place to start.
3. New City Sushi
+1 845-639-6993
New City Sushi always feels like a local secret—no flash, just solid sushi that delivers every visit. The space is tidy and inviting, where you can linger over a meal or grab a quick bite. My first time here, I was surprised by how attentive the staff was, never rushing but always on hand when needed.
The menu features classic sushi staples done right, with generous portions and flavors that highlight the freshness of every ingredient. For me, their vegetable roll stands out with its crisp texture and balanced flavor.
If you’re in the mood for simplicity and quality, try the avocado cucumber roll or a plate of mixed nigiri. New City Sushi’s straightforward style makes it a reliable pick on any day.
4. KOBE Sushi & Lounge
Step inside KOBE Sushi & Lounge and you’ll sense something different—modern décor and a welcoming, laid-back mood. The seating is spacious, making it perfect for groups or an easy lunch. I remember coming here on a rainy afternoon; the sushi bar felt like an oasis, and the pace was just right for relaxing.
KOBE wins me over with their unique approach: familiar rolls elevated with a creative twist. Presentation matters here, and your sushi arrives looking thoughtful and appetizing. The menu caters to both the adventurous and the traditionalist.
For a taste of what they do best, opt for the Kobe vegetarian roll or the tempura sweet potato roll. Each dish reflects attention to detail and a fresh take on classic flavors. This spot is ideal when you want sushi and a stylish escape.
5. Miso Nara
Miso Nara is a small spot that’s easy to miss, but you’ll be glad if you don’t. My first impression was shaped by a friendly greeting and the quiet hum of locals stopping by for their regular fix. It’s a place where sushi feels almost homemade, with a clear focus on freshness and simplicity.
One key reason Miso Nara stands out is the hands-on approach—rolls are made to order, and you can taste the difference. The portions are generous, and nothing ever feels rushed or premade.
If you want something memorable, try their vegetable roll or the avocado maki. Both showcase the balance of flavors and care that define Miso Nara’s style. It’s a spot for comfort and quality, all in one.
6. Kobe Fusion Inc
Kobe Fusion Inc brings a fresh twist on sushi to New City. It’s attached to the popular Kobe Sushi & Lounge, and you can feel that same energy as soon as you walk in—lively, modern, and full of variety. My first visit felt like finding a secret that everyone else was already in on.
Prices here are reasonable, so you can enjoy more than a few different rolls without second thoughts. What drew me back was their playfulness with classic combinations and the obvious care in presentation—nothing looks out of place on the plate.
If you’re feeling adventurous, order a specialty sushi roll or their vegetable tempura roll. Bold flavors and an artful touch make Kobe Fusion Inc a go-to for anyone wanting both quality and a little excitement.
7. Cho Cho San
Cho Cho San offers a calm escape from the busy streets of New City. The serene atmosphere put me at ease as soon as I sat down, and service never felt rushed or distracted. This spot has a loyal following, and after a meal here, it’s easy to see why.
Sushi at Cho Cho San is all about refined flavors and clean, artful presentation. It was here I tasted a cucumber roll so crisp that it made ordinary veggie rolls seem basic by comparison. The portions strike a nice balance—not too heavy, but enough to satisfy.
The avocado roll, with its perfect texture, and the garden vegetable roll are both top picks for a light yet flavorful meal. For fans of simplicity done right, Cho Cho San stands out.
8. Momoyama Sushi House
Momoyama Sushi House is one of those places that manages to feel upscale and homey at the same time. My first visit, I noticed the quiet hum of regulars—always a sign you’re in the right spot. The dining room is tidy and comfortable, making it easy to relax and focus on the food.
Sushi here surprises with its freshness and attention to balance. Every roll is prepared with care and there’s never a sloppy piece in sight. Momoyama doesn’t overcomplicate things, letting the natural flavors shine.
If you stop in, try the asparagus maki or a sweet potato roll. Both are full of clean, bright flavors that capture what makes the menu special. It’s a great choice for both newcomers and longtime sushi fans.
9. No1 Sushi
No1 Sushi might sound bold, but the name suits the vibe. My first time here was on a whim, pulled in by the steady stream of happy takeout customers. The counter staff are fast and friendly, never missing a beat, and there’s a laid-back feel that keeps things easy.
The sushi is a solid blend of quality and value. Each piece is neatly made, and the menu mixes up Japanese favorites with a few Asian-inspired surprises. Freshness stands out—nothing sits around for long here.
Don’t miss the vegetable roll or the avocado maki. Both promise great texture and flavor, showing off No1 Sushi’s knack for keeping things light and satisfying. If you want reliable food in a hurry, this is the spot.
10. Unicorn
Unicorn has a playful name, but it backs up the charm with a fresh approach to sushi. The space is modern and inviting, perfect for both a quick lunch and a fun dinner out. My first time here, I noticed the care that went into every detail, from the plating to the friendly service.
Their menu is extensive, balancing classic favorites with a few creative options. Presentation is a highlight—each roll looks as good as it tastes, which adds to the overall experience.
Try the veggie tempura roll or the cucumber avocado roll. Both dishes are crisp, vibrant, and packed with fresh flavor. For anyone seeking sushi that’s as enjoyable to look at as it is to eat, Unicorn delivers.
More Things to Try in New City, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best sushi restaurants in New City, NY?
Some of the top spots include Mizu Asian Bistro & Japanese Steak House, Kumo Sushi, New City Sushi, and KOBE Sushi & Lounge. Each offers fresh, well-prepared sushi and a comfortable dining experience.
Are there vegetarian or vegan sushi options in New City?
Yes. Most sushi restaurants in New City offer vegetarian and vegan rolls, such as avocado rolls, cucumber rolls, and sweet potato rolls. Places like Kumo Sushi and Momoyama Sushi House have creative plant-based selections.
Can I find halal-friendly sushi in New City?
While traditional sushi is often halal-friendly when avoiding certain ingredients, it’s best to confirm with each restaurant. Many places offer rolls free from haram items, focusing on fish, vegetables, and cooked seafood alternatives.
Is takeout or delivery available for sushi in New City?
Most sushi spots in New City provide takeout and delivery, making it easy to enjoy fresh rolls at home. Check each restaurant’s website or call ahead for details and ordering options.
What’s a must-try sushi roll in New City?
For a classic experience, try a spicy salmon roll or vegetable tempura roll. These rolls highlight fresh ingredients and beautiful presentation—a staple across New City’s sushi scene.
