Few things spark joy for your taste buds like a plate of fresh sushi, and Ithaca’s sushi scene punches well above its weight. Maybe it’s the college-town energy or just pure necessity, but this city has managed to draw in sushi chefs who aren’t coasting on fried rolls and cheap tricks. After lengthy lunches and chopstick duels with indecisive friends, I’ve mapped the city’s best sushi spots, each with its own distinct strength. If you crave buttery salmon, crisp nori, or a roll that treats rice as more than just a vehicle, Ithaca won’t disappoint.
You don’t have to settle for soggy seaweed or slabs of tuna straight from the freezer. Everything here—the ambiance, rice, wasabi, and everything else—gets put to the test. Some places delight with precision-cut sashimi, while others lure you in with creative combos and a perfectly balanced soy sauce. I’ve sorted the gems from the rest, so keep your appetite sharp—your future favorite roll could be on this list.
Where to find the best sushi in Ithaca, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best sushi in Ithaca, NY:
- Asia Cuisine
- Sumo Japanese Hibachi Sushi
- Mitsuba
- Plum Tree
- Spring Buffet
- Sushi Osaka
- Mitsuba Hibachi & Sushi Restaurant
- Sumo Japanese Steak House
- Tokyo Hibachi
- Thai Basil
1. Asia Cuisine
+1 607-256-8818
Asia Cuisine sits tucked off Route 79, but it’s hard to miss if you listen for the satisfied sighs after a good meal. This spot balances classic sushi with just enough creativity—serving quality, not gimmicks. The sliced salmon is always silky, the seaweed never chewy.
On my last visit, I started with the avocado roll, then caved for their spicy tuna. Both were flavorful, with rice that was warm and spot-on in texture. Here, sushi isn’t drowned in sauces or rolled with abandon; each piece is neat and well-balanced.
Don’t overthink it—try the yellowtail scallion or eel cucumber roll. Asia Cuisine delivers fresh, consistent sushi that feels crafted, not rushed.
2. Sumo Japanese Hibachi Sushi
Sumo Japanese Hibachi Sushi feels lively the moment you walk in. Whether you’re watching the hibachi show or settling in for a focused sushi feast, the bustle never distracts from the freshness. Sumo delivers sushi that’s both artful and satisfying, with clean flavors in every bite.
My favorite stop here: the Salmon Lover’s Roll. Every bite melts away doubt about what to order next. Their vegetarian rolls—think sweet potato, cucumber, or avocado—show the same care as the sashimi. Each roll arrives with perfect rice that never clumps or falls apart.
If you’re meeting friends or family, Private Dining ups the experience. Sumo nails consistency, a must when sushi cravings call.
3. Mitsuba
Mitsuba sits just off Triphammer Road, a calm refuge when you need a sushi fix that’s equal parts fresh and consistent. The presentation here steals the show—each roll arrives tidy, with vibrant cuts that look almost too good to eat.
I’m partial to their sushi lunch specials. The tuna avocado roll never fails—ripe avocado paired with silky fish, wrapped just tight enough. Sometimes, the veggie rolls turn out to be the surprise standout, brimming with bright cucumber and pickled radish.
Service is swift, so you won’t be left longing while you stare at the menu. If you’re after well-crafted rolls and a relaxed vibe, Mitsuba has you covered.
4. Plum Tree
Plum Tree has a steady following and for good reason—it’s a sushi classic that doesn’t mess around with trends. The fish here is always fresh, and each bite proves they value well-sourced ingredients over flash.
I keep returning for their cucumber avocado rolls. They’re creamy, crisp, and unpretentious, highlighting the essentials of good sushi. If you’re set on something heartier, their spicy tuna delivers real heat without overwhelming the fish.
Service is no-fuss and quick, perfect for an easygoing meal. Plum Tree quietly excels at reliable sushi prepared by steady hands—no dramatics, just quality with every visit.
5. Spring Buffet
+1 607-277-7888
Spring Buffet blends the joy of choice with the satisfaction of good sushi, all at a price that’s hard to resist. This isn’t your typical buffet—sushi gets its own spotlight, refreshed often so nothing sits around long.
My sweet spot: the veggie rolls. The cucumber and avocado rolls always seem crisp, and each bite is cool and balanced—a pleasant surprise in a buffet spread. If you’re dining with a group, the variety will keep everyone happy, but you’ll keep circling back to the sushi station.
Quick service and self-serve style mean you can eat at your own pace. For value-focused sushi fans, Spring Buffet hits the mark without sacrificing quality.
6. Sushi Osaka
Sushi Osaka feels like you’ve stumbled onto something secret, right on East State Street. The setting is simple, but the sushi brings a pop of freshness that leaves a lasting impression. Nothing here is drowned in sauce or stacked with unnecessary extras—everything stays true to classic flavors.
On my visit, the veggie rolls stood out. The avocado rolls had that perfect creaminess, while the cucumber was crisp and cooling. The rice was well-seasoned and each piece held together, even when dunked in a touch of soy sauce.
If you’re new, start with their maki rolls. Sushi Osaka delivers straightforward, spot-on sushi in a relaxed setting—good for quick bites or lingering meals.
7. Mitsuba Hibachi & Sushi Restaurant
Mitsuba Hibachi & Sushi Restaurant is where you can settle in for a no-stress sushi night or catch an entertaining hibachi experience. The calm, modern dining room lets the sushi take center stage, with presentation that’s always on point.
Every time I stop by, I make a beeline for their vegetable rolls. The cucumber and avocado rolls are always crisp, balanced, and just the right size to savor in a few perfect bites. Sashimi comes beautifully cut, showing the same neat attention to detail.
Service is unhurried but attentive. Whether you’re a sushi purist or love tasting a bit of everything, Mitsuba Hibachi & Sushi serves up reliably good sushi every single visit.
8. Sumo Japanese Steak House
Sumo Japanese Steak House draws you in with its lively energy and an impressive variety of sushi, tucked in the Cayuga Mall. This is a spot where rolls arrive fast, but never feel rushed; quality comes with each order.
During my visit, the sweet potato roll was a standout—hot, crisp, and lightly sweet. Fresh avocado and cucumber rolls also shine for their balance and cool flavors. The sushi menu favors accessible classics, so you can’t go wrong if you’re sticking to the tried and true.
Sumo delivers steady favorites, making it easy to bring a group or grab a quick bite. Their sushi strikes the right balance between comfort and freshness—never boring, always reliable.
9. Tokyo Hibachi
(607) 277-8888Call
Tokyo Hibachi sits on S Meadow Street and takes a playful approach to both hibachi and sushi, blending fun with no-nonsense flavors. The space is casual but the sushi is crafted with care, making it a pleasant surprise for those expecting ordinary.
For me, the avocado cucumber roll is a simple star—cool, crisp, and refreshingly light. The veggie maki selection is generous and each roll arrives with rice that’s soft but never sticky. You’ll notice each piece gets the same thoughtful construction, whether you order a single roll or a full platter.
If you bring friends, sharing is the way to go. Tokyo Hibachi excels at approachable, dependable sushi for those who like to keep things fresh and fuss-free.
10. Thai Basil
Thai Basil stands out on West State Street with a menu that finds harmony between Thai zest and sushi precision. The vibe is relaxed, the service unhurried, making it a spot where you can linger over conversation and a few good rolls.
My go-to is the veggie dragon roll—crisp cucumber and ripe avocado, topped with a delicate blanket of thinly sliced vegetables. Each bite is as balanced as it is colorful, with rice that’s polished and fluffy. Even the simplest rolls—like their avocado—feel considered, never thrown together.
If you’re looking to pair sushi with something from their Thai specialties, you’re in for a treat. Thai Basil blends comfort and creativity, a welcome change for sushi seekers who want more than the usual.
More Things to Try in Ithaca, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What sushi options are available for vegetarians in Ithaca?
Most sushi spots in Ithaca offer a range of vegetarian rolls. Look for avocado, cucumber, or sweet potato rolls, and many places can customize rolls to fit your preference.
Which sushi restaurants in Ithaca have takeout?
Nearly every sushi place on this list, including Mitsuba, Sumo Japanese Hibachi Sushi, and Plum Tree, offers takeout. Call ahead or check their websites for online ordering options.
Is there affordable sushi in Ithaca?
Yes, several restaurants like Spring Buffet and Sumo Japanese Steak House serve budget-friendly sushi that doesn’t compromise on quality or freshness.
Where can I find gluten-free sushi in Ithaca?
Sumo Japanese Hibachi Sushi clearly marks their gluten-free options, and many other places can prepare rolls without soy sauce or with gluten-free substitutes if you ask.
Are there places in Ithaca for sushi with a group?
Absolutely. Sumo Japanese Hibachi Sushi and Tokyo Hibachi are great for group gatherings, with options for private dining or tables large enough to share plenty of rolls.