Finding outstanding sushi in Goshen, NY doesn’t require a plane ticket to Tokyo—just a bit of local know-how and an adventurous spirit. Whether you’re after silky sashimi, perfectly rolled maki, or creative tempura options, this small Hudson Valley town offers a surprising handful of top sushi spots. Some are ideal for a cozy dinner, while others make a quick lunch feel special.
I remember wandering into a sushi bar one rainy evening in Goshen, thinking I’d end up with an average meal. Imagine my surprise when I was greeted with a menu that sparkled with freshness and a chef who took rice as seriously as an art critic studies portraits. It left me convinced that Goshen’s sushi scene can rival those of much larger cities—if you know where to look. If you’re new to town or simply want to upgrade your nigiri game, you’ve come to the right place. Let’s cut through the noise and find the best sushi Goshen and its neighbors have to offer.
Where to find the best sushi in Goshen, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best sushi in Goshen, NY:
- Mr Sushi & Grill
- Blue Finn Grill & Sushi
- O Sake Asian Fusion & Sake Bar
- Okaeri Sushi Hibachi
- Yune’s Sushi
- Blu Mango
- Umi Teriyaki
- Tuxedo Sushi
- Sushi Ya2
- Sushiville
1. Mr Sushi & Grill
Mr Sushi & Grill sits comfortably at the edge of Wallkill Plaza and serves up some of the freshest sushi in the Goshen area. Every piece here feels like it was made with care, and the staff treat you like a regular even on your first visit. If you value a welcoming atmosphere as much as your California roll, this is your spot.
On my last visit, I tried the Dragon Roll and the Salmon Avocado Roll. Both delivered the perfect blend of creamy and crisp, never overshadowing the subtlety of the fish. The presentation is always sharp—each plate looks ready for a magazine cover.
For a true taste of what they do best, start with any of the chef’s special rolls. You’ll leave thinking about your next visit before you’ve paid the check.
2. Blue Finn Grill & Sushi
Blue Finn Grill & Sushi marries inventive sushi with a laid-back dining room that never feels stuffy. There’s a buzz to this place—partly from the open kitchen, partly from plates flying out faster than you’d expect for such careful work. It’s a favorite for date night, but you’ll also spot locals dropping in for a casual bite at lunch.
I’m always impressed by their Tuna Lover’s Roll. The tuna melts in your mouth, matched by rice that’s just the right side of sticky. If you’re in the mood for something playful, the Sunshine Roll boasts a bright, refreshing flavor profile that feels tailor-made for sunny afternoons.
Portions here run a bit generous, so come hungry or bring a friend. The careful details on every plate prove that good sushi isn’t just for the big city.
3. O Sake Asian Fusion & Sake Bar
(845) 342-3208Call
O Sake Asian Fusion & Sake Bar brings a fresh, modern vibe to Main Street. This spot is all about blending creative sushi with Asian-inspired flair, making it perfect for both an adventurous night out and a quick, satisfying lunch. The décor walks the line between contemporary and cozy, so you can unwind while enjoying the show at the sushi bar.
My go-to is the Signature O Sake Roll. It reflects the kitchen’s skill—balanced flavors, cool crunch, and a hint of spice. If you like a mix of tradition and surprise, the Rainbow Roll layers texture with a variety of ultra-fresh fish.
The menu here isn’t just extensive, it’s exciting. Start with miso soup, and follow with their chef special rolls for a real sense of what this place can do.
4. Okaeri Sushi Hibachi
Okaeri Sushi Hibachi sits in a bustling Monroe shopping center, where it’s easy to spot crowds looking for a break from retail therapy. This place excels at balancing traditional sushi craftsmanship with showy hibachi flair. Whether you’re in for a quick sushi fix or dinner with a side of entertainment, Okaeri makes the experience memorable.
The first time I stopped in, the Okaeri Special Roll left an impression—beautifully plated, packed with flavor, and so fresh that each bite spoke for itself. The eel avocado roll is another favorite, with a buttery texture and a spot-on balance between sweet and savory.
Fans of classic rolls and those after something a little different will find both. Don’t skip the miso soup to round out your meal.
5. Yune’s Sushi
Yune’s Sushi makes its home in Gateway Plaza, quietly delivering expertly rolled sushi with a focus on freshness. The casual setup makes it easy to pop in for takeout or relax for a meal with friends. From my visits, it’s clear the kitchen takes care to get the details right, from fluffy rice to clean cuts of fish.
The Spicy Tuna Roll here has a reputation for good reason—it balances heat with flavor so well, you’ll want to order a second round. The Vegetable Roll is crisp and bright, perfect for those who want something lighter.
If you’re after consistency and quality, Yune’s easily makes the cut. For an added treat, try their daily chef’s special for something creative and fresh.
6. Blu Mango
(845) 713-4820Call
Blu Mango in Walden feels like a hidden gem for anyone exploring the sushi scene near Goshen. With vivid fusion flavors and a sleek, modern interior, it’s one of those places that invites you to slow down and savor every bite. The ambiance works for almost any occasion, from date night to catching up with old friends.
Last time I stopped by, I was drawn to the Mango Avocado Roll—an unexpected pairing where creamy and tart played off each other. The Shrimp Tempura Roll is also worth mentioning, wrapped in perfect rice with just the right crunch.
Blu Mango’s approach feels playful, yet skillful. If you crave something both approachable and unique, their signature fusion rolls are a must-try.
7. Umi Teriyaki
Umi Teriyaki makes sushi breaks possible, even in the midst of a marathon shopping day at Woodbury Common. Known for quick, fuss-free service and reliable fresh rolls, it’s a lifesaver when you want something satisfying but not heavy.
My last visit was during the lunch rush, yet the Salmon Roll came out fast and tasted just as good as any upscale spot. If you’re feeling a bit more traditional, the Cucumber Maki is crisp, cold, and hits the spot without weighing you down.
This isn’t fine dining, but that’s not the point. Umi Teriyaki nails the basics and delivers a solid, affordable sushi experience right where you need it most.
8. Tuxedo Sushi
Tuxedo Sushi is tucked away along Route 17, serving up sushi with a distinct Korean twist that sets it apart from the usual fare. The setting is calm and relaxed, making it just right for both solo dinners and family gatherings. What stands out most is the attention to detail—the staff and chefs make sure you notice.
On my first visit, the Rainbow Roll was a highlight. It struck a balance between flavor and freshness that’s tough to beat. The Sweet Potato Roll also shows off their creative side, bringing a subtle sweetness without overpowering the meal.
If you’re after something a bit different, explore their Korean-inspired rolls. Tuxedo Sushi blends tradition with a bit of adventurous flair, and it works.
9. Sushi Ya2
Sushi Ya2 brings a bit of Japanese flair to Vernon Valley Plaza, just a drive from Goshen. The inviting setup and friendly team set the tone as soon as you walk in. It’s a great stop if you want high-quality sushi without a big-city fuss. What I love here is how each roll feels hand-crafted, never rushed or cookie-cutter.
The Yellowtail Jalapeño Roll is worth the trip—fresh, with a kick that lingers in the best way. For classic comfort, the Cucumber Avocado Roll is always crisp and light. Sushi Ya2 isn’t about flash; it’s about quietly excellent sushi that lets fresh ingredients do the work.
If you like chefs who treat sushi as an art form, this spot deserves a place on your list.
10. Sushiville
Sushiville, right off Orange Turnpike, is a reliable stop for those who appreciate classic sushi done exceptionally well. The place has an easy-going feel, which is perfect for unwinding after a busy day or grabbing a quick lunch. The team here brings a personal touch to every order, welcoming regulars and first-timers with the same attention.
One memorable bite was the Spicy Salmon Roll—zesty and rich, balanced by just the right amount of heat. The Avocado Roll is another go-to, showcasing perfectly ripe slices that melt in your mouth.
The menu isn’t overwhelming, but what they do, they do well. Sushiville is proof that simplicity and quality are sometimes all you need.
More Things to Try in Goshen, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the top sushi restaurants in Goshen, NY?
Some of the top picks for sushi around Goshen include Mr Sushi & Grill, Blue Finn Grill & Sushi, and O Sake Asian Fusion & Sake Bar. Each offers a unique atmosphere and standout rolls.
Can I find vegetarian or vegan sushi in Goshen?
Absolutely. Many local sushi bars offer vegetarian options such as avocado rolls, cucumber rolls, and specialty veggie rolls. Most places are also happy to customize if you ask.
Is takeout sushi available in Goshen, NY?
Yes. Nearly every sushi restaurant in Goshen and surrounding areas provides takeout options. Ordering ahead by phone or online makes it even easier.
Which sushi spots in Goshen offer the freshest fish?
Mr Sushi & Grill and Yune’s Sushi are frequently praised for the freshness of their fish. Consistency is key at these locations.
Are there sushi places open late in Goshen?
Hours vary, but some places like Blue Finn Grill & Sushi stay open into the evening. It’s always a good idea to check ahead, especially on weekends.
What should I order for a first-time sushi eater?
Start with a California Roll or Avocado Roll. Both are approachable and let you get a feel for sushi flavors without anything too bold.