Finding sushi that stuns the taste buds in Garden City, NY, can feel like a search for buried treasure. Locals whisper about spicy tuna rolls that melt away stress and nigiri that seems almost too pretty to eat. I’ve had my fill of disappointing takeout, so when a Garden City spot gets sushi right, it stands out. One night after a long week, I remember walking into a cozy neighborhood sushi restaurant and realizing halfway through my first salmon roll that I’d struck gold.
If you love seafood but need your sushi prepared with care, creativity, and freshness, you’re in for a good read. Garden City is packed with hidden gems—from elegant sit-down places to laid-back sushi bars where chefs craft every plate like an artwork. This list highlights ten spots, all committed to delivering memorable, halal-friendly bites, so you can order with confidence. Ready to explore the real stars of Garden City’s sushi scene?
Where to find the best sushi in Garden City, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best sushi in Garden City, NY:
- Kinha Sushi
- Taku Asian Bistro Restaurant
- Sushi Ya
- Kaji Sushi
- International Buffet Incorporated
- Sushi Fuji
- Primehouse
- Nomiya
- kinha sushi inc
- Poke Frisée
1. Kinha Sushi
Kinha Sushi at 988 Franklin Ave always feels both relaxed and refined. The first time I visited, I noticed how attentive the staff are, striking a perfect balance between hospitality and efficiency. The minimalist décor lets the sushi steal the show, and the menu is a playground for anyone seeking fresh, inventive rolls.
Their Garden City Roll—brimming with tuna, avocado, and a touch of crunch—instantly became my go-to. The salmon nigiri is smooth and pristine, showing off the chef’s knife skills and respect for top-quality fish. Vegetarian options are crafted with the same flair, making Kinha Sushi an easy choice if you’re eating with a mixed group. If you crave sushi that’s equal parts flavor and finesse, start here.
2. Taku Asian Bistro Restaurant
Taku Asian Bistro Restaurant is the kind of place where the sushi bar buzzes with quiet energy and regulars swap recommendations over lunch. I first stumbled on Taku during a weekday break, lured in by the promise of creative rolls in a bright, clean space.
The standout here is their Mango Avocado Roll—each bite balances sweet and savory with surprising freshness. The chefs craft every plate with obvious care, whether you lean toward delicate veggie sushi or crave a classic cucumber roll. If you’re with friends, their sushi platters offer varied tastes and make sharing easy.
Taku shines for its friendly staff, inventive menu, and ability to keep things light yet satisfying. You’ll want to come back—and soon.
3. Sushi Ya
Sushi Ya offers a refreshing spin on classic Japanese fare, right in the heart of Garden City. Stepping inside, I always notice the friendly chatter and the gentle hum from the open sushi bar. There’s a casual, welcoming vibe that makes solo lunches or big group dinners equally comfortable.
Their Avocado Cucumber Roll is a staple—clean, crisp, and layered with just enough flavor to keep things interesting. What keeps me coming back is the surprising range of options. Everything from their lightly torched veggie rolls to hand-pressed nigiri feels thoughtful and fresh. If you’re unsure where to start, order the Garden City Special Roll for a playful mix of textures and tastes.
Sushi Ya makes it easy to mix familiar comfort with just a hint of adventure, all in under an hour.
4. Kaji Sushi
Kaji Sushi brings a calm, unhurried mood to Franklin Ave, making it a welcome retreat from the bustle outside. On my last visit, I watched the chefs glide through each order with obvious pride—precision and care in every slice.
The stand-out is their Vegetable Tempura Roll, which strikes that rare balance between crisp and delicate. There’s a sense of purpose behind the menu, where even the miso soup comes out steaming and packed with umami. For those craving something a bit more creative, the Sweet Potato Roll is a warm, comforting pick that reflects Kaji’s thoughtful touch.
Whether you’re planning a celebratory dinner or just need a low-key lunch, Kaji Sushi feels like a local secret you’ll want to share.
5. International Buffet Incorporated
International Buffet Incorporated is where abundance meets variety. My first visit felt a bit like discovering a sushi playground—large platters, endless choices, and every dish watched over carefully by staff who seem to know regulars by name.
The sushi options are always fresh, especially their Veggie Rolls and Avocado Maki, which are reliable picks for both regulars and newcomers. There’s something fun about sampling your way through a rainbow of rolls, each with its own textures and flavors. What makes the buffet experience enjoyable here is the attention to detail. Sushi is restocked often, and quality stays steady throughout the day.
If you crave variety without sacrificing freshness, International Buffet Incorporated delivers generous, crowd-pleasing sushi with ease.
6. Sushi Fuji
Sushi Fuji at Roosevelt Field Mall is proof that quick eats don’t have to compromise on flavor. I stopped by while shopping and was surprised by the quality behind the counter—chefs worked fast but never rushed, serving sushi that tasted bright and clean, not pre-packed.
The Avocado Roll is a dependable classic—smooth, fresh, and just the right amount of rice every time. Here, vegetable options shine, especially the Cucumber and Kampyo rolls, each bite as crisp as the last. Sushi Fuji’s menu is compact but focused, making it easy to mix and match to suit your mood.
If you crave a sushi break between errands, this spot hits the mark with quality and convenience that’s hard to find in a mall setting.
7. Primehouse
Primehouse brings a polished edge to Franklin Ave, famous for its steaks but with a sushi selection that rivals dedicated spots. The vibe leans upscale, yet staff make everyone feel at home. On my first dinner visit, I was drawn to the open sushi bar—the chefs, focused and fast, created plates that looked almost too good to eat.
The Avocado-Asparagus Roll is a quiet star—creamy yet crisp, wrapped in the perfect balance of rice and seaweed. Sushi here leans toward fresh, clean flavors with a creative twist, making room for both the classics and more imaginative bites. Whether you’re with friends or looking for a special-occasion treat, Primehouse delivers quality without skipping on style.
8. Nomiya
+1 516-916-2923
Nomiya has the low-key charm of a sushi spot you want to keep to yourself but can’t help mentioning to friends. When I ducked in for a quick lunch, I was greeted by a peaceful ambiance that made it easy to unwind and focus on the food.
The highlight for me was their Avocado & Cucumber Roll—refreshing, tidy, and full of honest flavor with each bite. Nomiya doesn’t aim to overwhelm with a giant menu. Instead, it sticks to reliable favorites, prepared with extra attention to freshness and detail. For something a bit more inventive, their mixed vegetable rolls stack up colorful taste and texture in every slice.
If you’re after neat, unfussy sushi that doesn’t compromise on quality, Nomiya is worth a visit.
9. kinha sushi inc
kinha sushi inc is tucked away in a cozy storefront, making it feel like a true neighborhood find. I wandered in on a rainy afternoon and found the setting both inviting and relaxed. The staff greeted me with genuine warmth and the menu was a pleasant surprise—offering both Japanese and Thai options, but it’s the sushi that shines.
The standout is their Sweet Potato Roll, which arrives perfectly crisp on the outside and soft inside, delivering comfort in every bite. Their fresh Vegetable Rolls and Avocado Maki show off clean flavors and a delicate hand. The portions are generous without being overwhelming, making it easy to sample a few different rolls in one visit.
For Garden City locals craving friendly service and satisfying, halal-friendly sushi, kinha sushi inc is smart and consistent.
10. Poke Frisée
+1 516-730-3401
Poke Frisée feels like a breath of fresh air, blending Japanese and Hawaiian flavors in a sunlit, cheerful space. My first visit was on a busy afternoon—the place buzzed with regulars picking up bright poke bowls and sushi rolls. What caught my eye was the steady stream of people coming for a quick yet healthy bite.
The Vegetable Sushi Rolls deliver on both presentation and taste, with each piece perfectly balanced between rice and crisp vegetables. Their signature poke bowls offer plenty of customization, so you get exactly what you crave without worry. You’ll find the ingredients are always fresh, and the flavors pop without being heavy.
If you like your sushi with a creative twist and speedy service, Poke Frisée is a Garden City staple.
More Things to Try in Garden City, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the top sushi spots in Garden City, NY?
Garden City offers a range of great options like Kinha Sushi, Sushi Ya, Kaji Sushi, and Taku Asian Bistro Restaurant. Each has its own style, from inventive rolls to classic nigiri and creative vegetarian selections.
Can I find vegetarian sushi in Garden City?
Absolutely. Most sushi restaurants in Garden City offer vegetarian choices, such as avocado rolls, cucumber rolls, sweet potato rolls, and mixed veggie options. Spots like Kaji Sushi and Poke Frisée are especially popular for plant-forward sushi.
Is there halal-friendly sushi in Garden City?
Yes, many Garden City sushi spots offer halal-friendly and seafood-focused dishes. Be sure to ask about ingredients if you have specific dietary needs—staff are usually knowledgeable and eager to help.
Are there affordable sushi options in Garden City?
You don’t need to splurge to enjoy good sushi. Places like Sushi Fuji and International Buffet Incorporated offer fresh rolls at accessible prices, perfect for lunches or quick bites.
Which sushi restaurants take reservations or offer takeout?
Most sushi spots, including Kinha Sushi, Sushi Ya, and Primehouse, offer reservations and takeout. Calling ahead is a good idea, especially during busy dinner hours.
Where can I get sushi platters for parties or events?
Many Garden City restaurants, such as Kinha Sushi and Taku Asian Bistro Restaurant, can prepare custom sushi platters for gatherings. Advance notice helps ensure you get the best variety for your event.