Hunting for the best sushi in Farmingville, NY isn’t just about tracking down good rice and fresh fish. It’s about finding that spot where a single bite tells you the chef knows their craft—and has a respect for ingredients that sometimes borders on obsession. I still remember the first time I tried sushi in Farmingville. A modest roll at a family-owned spot turned a quick bite into a full-blown quest for the perfect nigiri. That day, chopsticks became more than utensils. They became my ticket to exploring the community’s hidden gems.
Farmingville’s sushi scene isn’t glamorous on the surface. There are no red carpets, but there are tables where flavors shine without compromise. Whether you’re after melt-in-your-mouth tuna or inventive rolls with a playful twist, the area’s kitchens offer more than meets the eye. This guide pulls together years of sampling, conversations with locals, and the real delight of discovering a new favorite. Ready? Your next top sushi spot is probably just around the corner.
Where to find the best sushi in Farmingville, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best sushi in Farmingville, NY:
- Sam’s Sushi Bistro
- Tofu Chinese & Japanese Restaurant
- New Sushi Palace
- Nishiki Sushi Hibachi Restaurant
- 360 Taiko Sushi & Lounge
- Tang’s Dynasty
- Machi Sushi
- Umami Sushi & Bar
- Golden Buffet
- Hoshi Sushi and Hibichi
1. Sam’s Sushi Bistro
Sam’s Sushi Bistro tucks itself into Farmingville with the attitude of a local favorite. The space feels welcoming, with staff who remember faces and aren’t shy about recommending their best rolls. The first time I sat down here, I noticed how quickly regulars’ names were called out—a sign that this spot runs on familiarity and flair.
What sets Sam’s apart isn’t just hospitality, but the attention paid to each piece of sushi. The Salmon Avocado Roll lands artfully arranged, bursting with freshness, while the Tuna Sashimi shows off texture that’s difficult to match nearby. Presentation is simple, flavor never is.
If you’re in the mood to share, try their assorted sushi platters. The quality of the fish, paired with just-right rice, makes for a meal that lingers in memory—an easy standout on the Farmingville sushi map.
2. Tofu Chinese & Japanese Restaurant
Tofu Chinese & Japanese Restaurant makes dining both simple and satisfying in Farmingville. It’s the kind of place where you can drop in for a casual weekday lunch or take your time over dinner with friends. My last visit was sparked by curiosity, but it’s their balance of quality and price that keeps me coming back.
The menu blends Japanese tradition and Chinese comfort classics, but sushi is where they quietly impress. Their Yellowtail Scallion Roll speaks to both freshness and well-balanced flavor. The Vegetable Sushi Combination stands out for anyone looking for lighter, vivid tastes while sticking to plant-based options.
The staff here move with an easy efficiency, and portions are generous. Tofu makes sushi accessible—a real bonus for anyone who loves trying a bit of everything.
3. New Sushi Palace
New Sushi Palace is a reliable stop for sushi fans with big appetites or groups in tow. I first walked in on a rainy evening, craving something comforting but fresh, and found the bustling dining room washing away any doubt. The pace is lively, but there’s real attention to detail on every plate.
The main draw here? Generous sushi portions and a broad menu. Their Sushi Deluxe offers a variety of nigiri and rolls, each piece delicate in flavor and neatly prepared. The Spicy Tuna Roll, a favorite of mine, is sharp with just enough kick—not drowning in sauce, but shining on its own merit.
If you want to sample widely, this is a spot where quality and quantity meet without compromise.
4. Nishiki Sushi Hibachi Restaurant
Nishiki Sushi Hibachi Restaurant isn’t just a local dinner option—it’s a gathering place with energy in every seat. I once visited for a birthday dinner, where the hum of the hibachi grills kept the conversation flowing and the food arriving fast. The staff are unfailingly friendly, stepping in with expert suggestions if you linger too long over the menu.
Diving into their Sushi Boat for Two is a treat, brimming with vibrant nigiri and signature rolls that showcase fresh, properly sliced fish. Their Avocado Cucumber Roll is always crisp, offering a clean bite every time. What stands out here is the care put into quality—rice is well seasoned, and portions are generous without being overwhelming.
If you want atmosphere along with authenticity, Nishiki delivers both, subtly setting itself apart in a crowded field.
5. 360 Taiko Sushi & Lounge
360 Taiko Sushi & Lounge is where classic sushi mingles with a modern vibe. The first time I walked in, the lighting and gentle background music made it feel like a special occasion, even on a casual Tuesday. The staff here keep the mood relaxed but attentive, ready with suggestions if you’re feeling adventurous.
The menu is broad, but their creative sushi rolls truly shine. The Vegetable Dragon Roll layers flavors beautifully, with ripe avocado and just the right touch of sweetness. For something elegant, the Eel Cucumber Roll is a consistent favorite, thanks to its clean, balanced taste and delicate presentation.
360 Taiko manages to feel both lively and laid-back—a go-to when you want sushi that’s as stylish as it is satisfying.
6. Tang’s Dynasty
(631) 588-8885Call
Tang’s Dynasty blends several Asian cuisines under one roof, but the sushi here draws me back every time. The first time I visited, I was pleasantly surprised by how welcoming the staff were, guiding me through their sushi options with genuine interest. There’s a sense that each order matters, no matter how small.
For sushi lovers, the Sweet Potato Roll has a perfect crunch and a subtle sweetness that pairs well with their pickled ginger. Their California Roll is simple but balanced, offering a classic option that never disappoints. The rice stays fluffy, and the ingredients always seem fresh.
Tang’s Dynasty stands out for its generosity and approachability. It’s a comfortable spot to bring friends or grab a quick solo bite—affordable and unfussy, but always reliable.
7. Machi Sushi
Machi Sushi has a low-key presence, but don’t let that fool you. Walking in feels like joining a well-kept secret in the Farmingville area. My visit proved that the buzz is more than justified. The staff work quickly, but every plate arrives with presentation that feels intentional, not rushed.
What defines Machi Sushi is the consistency and pure flavors. Their Salmon Sushi melts in your mouth, each piece the right blend of cool fish and gently seasoned rice. If you’re in the mood for a roll, try the Avocado Cucumber Roll—simple ingredients, executed flawlessly.
Whether you’re stopping by for a quiet dinner or ordering takeout, Machi Sushi delivers the kind of quality that encourages repeat visits. It’s a no-nonsense spot where sushi takes center stage.
8. Umami Sushi & Bar
Umami Sushi & Bar feels like a hidden staple for those who appreciate quiet charm over flash. The first time I sat down here, it was for an impromptu lunch that quickly turned into a slow, satisfying meal. The vibe is relaxed, the staff are friendly, and everything comes out looking as good as it tastes.
The star at Umami? Sushi crafted with precision and care. The Tuna Avocado Roll brings together tender fish and creamy avocado without overwhelming the palate. Their Vegetable Roll is always crisp and fresh, proving that simple combinations can pack real flavor.
It’s the sort of place that flies under the radar, but each visit is a gentle reminder of why sushi sometimes needs little more than good fish and skilled hands.
9. Golden Buffet
Golden Buffet brings you the rare joy of unlimited choice, especially when you’re in a sushi mood with a group. I dropped in with friends, each of us chasing a different craving, and somehow everyone left satisfied. It’s easy to see why, with sushi sharing space alongside a wide range of other Asian favorites.
The sushi here is approachable and plentiful—not fussy, just fresh enough to make sampling fun. The Salmon Roll is always a dependable pick, with gentle flavor and good texture. Their Cucumber Avocado Roll offers a light counterpoint for those seeking a meatless bite.
Golden Buffet is a solid pick for families and groups, where you can try a little of everything and never feel rushed.
10. Hoshi Sushi and Hibichi
Hoshi Sushi and Hibichi is where you go when you want an experience to match your meal. My first dinner here was filled with energy—chefs flipping knives behind the hibachi grill while laughter spilled from nearby tables. The sushi menu doesn’t get lost in the spectacle; in fact, it holds its own.
The Tuna Mango Roll is a crowd pleaser, fusing sweet mango and savory tuna in a combo that never feels gimmicky. Their Avocado Asparagus Roll is fresh and satisfying, a choice that proves simple ingredients done right can stand out.
Service always feels attentive, and the atmosphere is lively without being overbearing. For sushi that is both fun and fresh, Hoshi finds a sweet spot.
More Things to Try in Farmingville, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What are the most popular sushi rolls in Farmingville, NY?
A: Classic favorites like the California Roll, Spicy Tuna Roll, and Salmon Avocado Roll are widely enjoyed. Many spots also offer signature rolls unique to their menu with creative combinations.
Q: Are there vegetarian or vegan sushi options in Farmingville?
A: Yes, almost every sushi place in Farmingville offers vegetarian rolls such as Cucumber Roll, Avocado Roll, and creative mixed vegetable rolls for plant-based diners.
Q: Is sushi in Farmingville suitable for halal diets?
A: Many local sushi restaurants offer fish and vegetarian options that can fit a halal diet. It’s always a good idea to confirm preparation details with the restaurant if you have specific dietary needs.
Q: Can I find affordable sushi in Farmingville?
A: Definitely. Farmingville has a range of sushi restaurants with prices for every budget, from casual buffets to more upscale bars and bistros.
Q: Do sushi spots in Farmingville offer takeout or delivery?
A: Yes. Most sushi restaurants in the area offer both takeout and delivery, making it easy to enjoy your favorite rolls at home.