Everyone has their own sushi story. Mine began in Centereach on a random Tuesday, lured in by the low-key glow behind a strip mall window. That night, chopsticks in hand, I dove past the usual California rolls and found the true spirit of local sushi—fresh slabs of tuna, perfectly tangy rice, authentic detail in every slice. Since then, I’ve explored Centereach’s sushi scene with curiosity and a very picky palate.
If you think Long Island only does pizza and bagels, you’re missing out. Centereach hides some serious sushi talent, each spot with its secret weapon—be it melt-in-your-mouth salmon or a hidden spicy tuna masterpiece. This guide covers the spots worth your time (and appetite). Expect personal insights, the strongest contenders for top-tier rolls, and absolutely no haram ingredients.
Where to find the best sushi in Centereach, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best sushi in Centereach, NY:
- New Sushi Palace
- Umani Sushi and Bar
- Golden Buffet
- Umami Sushi & Bar
- DingDing Foodies Inc
- Nishiki Sushi Hibachi Restaurant
- Wild Ginger
- Tang’s Dynasty
- Sam’s Sushi Bistro
- Machi Sushi
1. New Sushi Palace
New Sushi Palace feels like Centereach’s go-to for a sushi night out. The dining room is unpretentious, but the sushi grabs your attention from the start. I still think about the first time I ordered the chef’s special roll—layers of fresh fish, with avocado and a hint of wasabi, all balanced just right.
What gives New Sushi Palace the edge is their approach: portion sizes are generous and the rice always lands that perfect texture. The staff aren’t just fast; they remember regulars and even recommend new rolls if you’re stuck.
For a signature experience, try their spicy tuna roll or classic salmon nigiri. Both showcase the freshness that keeps regulars coming back for more.
2. Umani Sushi and Bar
Umani Sushi and Bar isn’t your typical strip mall spot. There’s a relaxed energy here, with low lighting and subtle music that give the space real charm. Last time I visited, the chef sent out a complimentary piece of seared tuna—simple, fresh, and packed with flavor. It made me want to try everything else on the menu.
Umani stands out for its creative rolls and careful attention to detail. The menu has vegetarian options that actually fill you up and never shortchange on taste. Service is welcoming without being overbearing.
If you’re torn on what to order, go for the Dragon Roll or their Yellowtail Jalapeño appetizer. Each dish is artfully presented, bringing together fresh fish and flavor combinations that always work.
3. Golden Buffet
Golden Buffet offers a laid-back, all-you-can-eat approach that’s perfect if you want variety without formality. My last visit was during a rainy weekend—ideal for filling plates without judgment. I found myself returning to the sushi station, drawn by their steady turnover of fresh rolls and made-to-order nigiri.
This isn’t fine dining, but it’s reliable, fresh, and perfect for group outings or solo feasts. The staff keeps everything replenished, so you’re never left with tired or limp choices. Plus, the price point makes experimentation feel guilt-free.
Try the eel avocado roll and the classic vegetable rolls. Both reflect Golden Buffet’s strength: accessible, satisfying sushi that delivers value and taste in equal measure.
4. Umami Sushi & Bar
Umami Sushi & Bar feels like a step up from the average local spot. I still remember my last meal there: the chef greeted each customer, making real recommendations based on what was freshest that day. It felt far more personal than most places in town.
What sets Umami apart is their ability to combine classic technique with modern flair. You’ll see artfully plated signature rolls alongside timeless sashimi that’s rich in flavor and presentation.
The Salmon Lover Roll is a standout—layers of salmon over rice with just enough crunch and creaminess to keep things interesting. If you appreciate thoughtful, well-prepared sushi, Umami is where you’ll want to linger for an extra roll or two.
5. DingDing Foodies Inc
(716) 584-3645Call
DingDing Foodies Inc is where variety rules. The first time I tried this spot, I wasn’t sure what to expect—it has a little bit of everything, but the sushi counter quickly became my focus. I noticed right away that the chefs didn’t skimp on freshness or creativity, weaving in subtle twists to classic rolls.
DingDing stands out for offering a fusion menu in a casual, no-fuss setting. It’s a go-to if you’re dining with people who all crave something different, but you want your sushi craving properly satisfied.
Order the spicy salmon roll and the cucumber avocado roll. Both show off how DingDing balances traditional technique and bold taste, all while keeping things approachable and fun.
6. Nishiki Sushi Hibachi Restaurant
Nishiki Sushi Hibachi Restaurant is a spot where dinner feels like an event. On my first visit, I was seated near the hibachi grill, but the sushi menu instantly caught my attention. The staff offered smart recommendations, knowing exactly which rolls were making guests happy that night.
Nishiki stands out due to its blend of lively hibachi energy and focused sushi craftsmanship. The kitchen balances showmanship with quality—every sushi roll arrives fresh, vibrant, and full of flavor.
The spicy tuna roll and the eel cucumber roll are highlights. Each bite shows that Nishiki hasn’t forgotten the art of fresh sushi, even in a space buzzing with hibachi action. Perfect for those who want it all in one place.
7. Wild Ginger
Wild Ginger offers a cozy break from Smithtown’s busy streets, just a short drive from Centereach. My own experience here involved an impromptu lunch that turned into a full sushi spread. The setting is peaceful, making it easy to linger over your meal and actually taste each detail.
This spot is known for its consistency in both taste and presentation. The sushi is always fresh, with portions that hit the sweet spot between generous and refined. Staff are quietly attentive, never hovering but always ready to guide you toward the day’s best picks.
Try the rainbow roll or the shrimp avocado roll. Both shine with fresh ingredients and show why Wild Ginger is a favorite among those who appreciate simple, well-done sushi.
8. Tang’s Dynasty
(631) 588-8885Call
Tang’s Dynasty is one of those places that covers all the bases without losing its charm. I ducked in once on a weeknight and was greeted by that unmistakable aroma of sushi rice and soy. The chef behind the counter chatted while crafting each roll, adding a welcome personal touch.
What sets Tang’s Dynasty apart is the fusion of different Asian cuisines, with sushi that’s both flavorful and balanced. The menu is approachable, and you get a solid mix of classic options alongside a few inventive surprises.
Order the spicy crunchy tuna roll or tempura sweet potato roll. Both showcase the kitchen’s knack for flavor and attention to ingredient quality—a solid bet for any sushi lineup in Centereach and beyond.
9. Sam’s Sushi Bistro
Sam’s Sushi Bistro gives off a friendly, almost neighborhood hangout vibe. My first visit was marked by the chef coming out to ask how the rolls landed—a small moment but one that stuck with me. There’s real pride in what they serve, and it shows on every plate.
The menu sets itself apart with creative twists on classic sushi, but without overwhelming the basics. Prices are fair, making it easy to try a few different things without regret. Service balances warmth and efficiency.
Don’t skip the green dragon roll or the yellowtail scallion roll. Freshness never falters, and both rolls are nicely packed, each bite bringing balanced flavors that highlight why Sam’s keeps a loyal following.
10. Machi Sushi
Machi Sushi stands just off Middle Country Road, quietly nailing the essentials with none of the fuss. I stopped in for a quick lunch one afternoon and ended up lingering longer than planned, thanks to the steady stream of sushi that never missed the mark.
Machi’s real appeal lies in its reliable quality and easygoing atmosphere. The sushi is always fresh, and there’s a clear focus on getting the small details right, from the rice texture to the precise slices of fish.
The tuna avocado roll and the vegetable tempura roll are both top picks. Each one is beautifully assembled, reflecting Machi’s reputation for careful, consistent craftsmanship without unnecessary flash.
More Things to Try in Centereach, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best sushi restaurants in Centereach, NY?
Centereach boasts several strong contenders. New Sushi Palace, Umami Sushi & Bar, and Sam’s Sushi Bistro are local favorites for freshness, value, and creativity.
Are there vegetarian sushi options in Centereach?
Absolutely. Many spots like Umani Sushi and DingDing Foodies Inc offer a variety of vegetarian rolls, with classics like avocado, cucumber, and sweet potato rolls on most menus.
Can I find sushi for takeout or delivery?
Most local sushi restaurants offer both options. Check each spot’s website or call to confirm if you need delivery, as some partner with third-party apps.
What’s the price range for sushi in Centereach?
Prices range from wallet-friendly buffets like Golden Buffet to mid-range options at places like Nishiki Sushi Hibachi and Machi Sushi. Expect to pay more for specialty rolls, but basic rolls are usually affordable.
Is the sushi fresh in Centereach restaurants?
The top-rated spots take freshness seriously. Rolls are usually made to order, and many chefs offer recommendations based on what’s best that day.